1803-1806 Rev. Henry Pottle
1806-1807 William Bentley
1807-1815 The church without a Pastor
1815-1816 Rev. Samuel Wydown
1816-1824 Rev. Ebenezer Nelson
1824-1825 Rev. John Cookson (author of first covenant)
1825-1826 The church without a Pastor
1826-1828 Rev. J.N. Brown
1828-1832 Rev. Avery Briggs
1832-1835 Rev. Corant Sawyer
1835-1837 The church without a Pastor
1837-1838 Rev. E.N. Harris (He embraces Universalism and was excommunicated from the Baptist Faith)
1838-1840 Rev. Joseph Driver
1840-1843 Rev. Nathaniel W. Williams (from Beverly, MA)
1843-1848 Rev. John Cookson (recalled)
1848-1850 Rev. Charles D. Smith
1851-1860 Rev. William Stubbert
1860-1866 Rev. Daniel W. Faunce
1866-1867 The church without a Pastor
1867-1870 Rev. Charles F. Warren
1870-1888 Rev. Samuel W. Foljambe
1888-1891 Rev. J. Nelson Lewis
1891-1892 Rev. N. H. Harriman
1892-1903 Rev. Henry Orrn Hiscox
1903-1919 Rev. Charles H. Moss
1919-1935 Rev. W. Quay Rosselle
1935-1944 Rev. George Arthur Clarke
1944-1945 Rev. Clark T. Brownell (retired-interim)
1945-1969 Rev. Hillyer Hawthorne Straton (died as Pastor)
1970-1976 Rev. George Sinclair, Jr.
1977-1983 Rev. George H. Tooze, Jr.
1983-1984 Rev. Robert G. Middleton (retired-interim)
1984-1995 Rev. David M. Kilpatrick
1995-1997 Ms. Martha A. Dominy (interim)
1997-2021 Rev. Martha A. Dominy
2021-2022 The church without a Pastor
2022-Present Rev. Gary McClenthen